|
| |
Transgenic crops (GMCs), main products of agricultural
biotechnology, are increasingly becoming a dominant feature of the agricultural
landscapes of the USA and other countries such as China, Argentina, Mexico and
Canada. Worldwide, the areas
planted to transgenic crops jumped more than twenty-fold in the past six years,
from 3 million hectares in 1996 to nearly 44.2 million hectares in 2000 (James
2000). In the USA, Argentina and
Canada, over half of the average for major crops such as soybean, corn and
canola are planted in transgenic varieties.
Herbicide resistant crops (HRC) and insect resistant crops (Bt crops)
accounted respectively for 59 and 15 percent of the total global area of all
transgenic crops in 2000. Transnational corporations (TNCs) such as Monsanto,
DuPont, Novartis, etc. which are the main proponents of biotechnology argue that
carefully planned introduction of these crops should reduce or even eliminate
the enormous crop losses due to weeds, insect pests, and pathogens. In fact,
they argue that the use of such crops will have added beneficial effects on the
environment by significantly reducing the use of agrochemicals (Krimsky and
Wrubel 1996). However, ecological theory predicts that as long as transgenic
crops follow closely the pesticide paradigm prevalent in modern agriculture,
such biotechnological products will do nothing but reinforce the pesticide
treadmill in agroecosystems, thus legitimizing the concerns that many
environmentalists and some scientists have expressed regarding the
possible environmental risks of genetically engineered organisms. In fact, there
are several widely accepted environmental drawbacks associated with the rapid
deployment and widespread commercialization of such crops in large monocultures,
including (Rissler and Mellon, 1996; Snow and Moran, 1997, Kendall et al l997,
Altieri 2000):
 |
the
spread of transgenes to related weeds or conspecifics via crop-weed
hybridization, |
 |
reduction
of the fitness of non-target organisms through the acquisition of transgenic
traits via hybridization. |
 |
the
rapid evolution of resistance of insect pests such as Lepidoptera to Bt |
 |
accumulation
of the insecticidal Bt toxin, which remains active in the soil after the
crop is ploughed under and binds tightly to clays and humic acids; |
 |
disruption
of natural control of insect pests through intertrophic-level effects of the
Bt toxin on predators; |
 |
unanticipated
effects on non-target herbivorous insects (i.e. monarch butterflies) through
deposition of transgenic pollen on foliage of surrounding wild vegetation
(Losey et al l999), and |
 |
vector-mediated
horizontal gene transfer and recombination to create new pathogenic
organisms |
In this paper
however we will focus on the known effects of the two dominant types of GMCs:
HRCs and Bt crops.
|